2025 Positional Power Rankings: Third Base

I’ve lengthy stated that José Ramírez is probably the most underrated participant of his technology, and it seems that gamers agree with me, as do a big share of followers and analysts. Ramírez is likely one of the two third basemen, together with Austin Riley, who go into any given season within the MVP dialog, and although he hasn’t landed the {hardware} but, he’s obtained votes in eight of the final 9 seasons and presently ranks forty second all-time in MVP share.

Ramírez is 32, however he’s in such rarified air that given a standard decline part, he isn’t more likely to fall into an issue space production-wise till properly into the 2030s. ZiPS sees him ending with round 2,500 hits, 70 WAR, and 58 JAWS; his standing in JAWS would put him ninth amongst third basemen, ending forward of contemporaries like Manny Machado and Nolan Arenado.

If third base is commonly a tweener place, populated by gamers who aren’t defensively gifted sufficient to be shortstops or offensively potent sufficient to be first basemen, Ramírez is likely one of the exceptions, as he’d be one of many prime first basemen within the sport, and sure might have performed a reputable shortstop earlier in his profession, although the presence of then-teammate Francisco Lindor made that pointless.

Ought to the Guardians lose Ramírez to a big damage, there’s no one on the roster who can exchange even half of his manufacturing. Gabriel Arias and Daniel Schneemann have worth as utility gamers, and so they would possibly platoon at third if the scenario referred to as for it, however any extended Ramírez absence might properly be sufficient to knock Cleveland out of the playoff race.

After three consecutive 5-WAR seasons, Austin Riley had a very down 2024, a typical theme for Atlanta’s beginning lineup. Nonetheless, a rib cage pressure and a damaged hand courtesy of a Jack Kochanowicz fastball have been mitigating components in what was simply his worst season since his 2021 breakout, and there’s little motive to assume that Riley can’t return to the elite tier of third basemen.

The projections a minimum of don’t give a lot motive for furrowed brows, as these weren’t accidents more likely to hinder him long-term. He hit like he usually does after getting back from his stomach damage, placing up an .846 OPS in July and August earlier than lacking the remainder of the season with the hand fracture. For a minimum of the following 4 or 5 years, Riley must be counted on for a wRC+ within the 125-135 vary and 35-40 homers a yr, offensive manufacturing you don’t get from the new nook. He’s not the glove man a few of the different prime third basemen are, however he’s hardly disastrous, and the times of questioning if he’ll find yourself at first base or in left discipline are lengthy behind him.

The backups right here recommend that the Braves have to be comfy with Riley’s well being and anticipated manufacturing, although they absolutely held their breath when a Jackson Rutledge fastball hit the slugger’s healed proper hand final week. Fortunately, the MRI confirmed no structural injury, and it’s not anticipated to be a difficulty transferring ahead.

Keep in mind when Matt Chapman’s second-half struggles in 2023 meant that he was in a steep offensive decline and that no workforce ought to contact him with a 39-and-a-half-foot pole? Keep in mind children: Pals don’t let associates overinterpret first half/second half splits. Chapman additionally demonstrated that his glove has a little bit of gold left in it; he was value 11 OAA and 17 DRS, and gained his fifth Gold Glove. He signed a six-year, $151 million deal to stick with the Giants final September.

Getting into his age-32 season, Chapman doesn’t come with out danger, however there’s no explicit motive for concern, a minimum of in 2025. And if league-wide offense ticks up in any respect, he has a combating probability to be San Francisco’s first 30-homer hitter since Barry Bonds in 2004. The Giants have respectable depth at third in Tyler Fitzgerald, Casey Schmitt, and Wilmer Flores, however the hope is to keep away from having to make use of it.

An elbow damage and ensuing surgical procedure meant that Manny Machado was restricted to DH responsibility initially of the 2024 season, however the Padres steadily elevated his time at third base in Could and June, and by the homestretch, Machado was again to enjoying the place full-time. When it was all stated and completed, he had put up a reasonably typical Manny Machado season, with ultimate numbers proper round his profession averages.

Machado turns 33 in July, so his greatest seasons are seemingly largely behind him, however his profile is mercifully quick on hazard indicators. He nonetheless hits the ball very onerous (48% hard-hit in 2024), his bat pace is in elite territory (83rd percentile), and his protection at third base remains to be greater than acceptable (+15 FRV over the past three years, and proper at common in 2024). The one actual decline Machado has skilled is his foot pace (right down to the fifteenth percentile), however that was by no means a giant a part of his sport.

There’s nobody on the roster whose presence signifies that San Diego has another plan than beginning Machado 150 occasions at third base in 2025. I like Eguy Rosario greater than most, but when the Padres have been inclined to provide him a bigger position on the sizzling nook, they seemingly would have completed so final yr when Machado was DHing. Tyler Wade’s principally round as a result of he’s a lefty bat, whereas the draw of Jose Iglesias is his skill to play the center infield.

Shedding Alex Bregman hurts, however the Astros did a surprisingly good job making up for his loss, regardless that it pressured them to half with Kyle Tucker a yr early. ZiPS completely adores Isaac Paredes in Houston, considerably greater than it did when he referred to as Wrigley Subject residence. That’s largely as a result of the park components in ZiPS make the most of a mannequin that considers whether or not a participant is a pull hitter or a sprig hitter. Paredes is an excessive pull hitter, and ZiPS believes he’ll thrive in Daikin Park. You would possibly level to his Statcast anticipated stats being lackluster as trigger for concern, however it’s a must to keep in mind that the longer a participant exceeds or falls in need of metrics like this, the extra a projection must imagine them.

The ultra-flexible Mauricio Dubón might be readily available for the occasional spot begin, and Luis Guillorme could catch a couple of begins as properly. Within the occasion of a big damage to Paredes, I’d like to see the Astros give Shay Whitcomb an actual look. Whitcomb was by no means actually on the prospect radar, however he’s hit for energy wherever he’s performed, and he made nice strides final yr when it comes to his plate self-discipline.

Among the many groups within the prime 10 of those rankings, that is simply probably the most unsure third base scenario. That might have been a stunning assertion three months in the past, what with Rafael Devers having simply turned in one other All-Star season on the sizzling nook, however Alex Bregman’s continued availability in free company became a chance for the Crimson Sox even because it has necessitated some infield shuffling.

Bregman’s peak might be behind him, however he’s nonetheless a top-10 third baseman, posting a 118 wRC+ and 4.1 WAR in 2024, and would appear the plain alternative for Boston if it doesn’t trigger a big rift within the clubhouse. He’s by no means been the defensive match of a Nolan Arenado or a Matt Chapman, however he’s at all times been solidly above common (as you’d hope for from a transformed shortstop), posting 6 OAA, 5 FRV and 6 DRS final yr.

Given his potent bat, Devers must be an absolute catastrophe at third for him to not be one of many place’s stars total. However with a greater defensive choice on the roster, enjoying Devers elsewhere is a no brainer, particularly given his gradual begin to spring motion as he works on his shoulder energy and tinkers together with his swing. Maybe that’s why he has appeared extra open to the thought in latest days after initially bristling on the suggestion. Nonetheless, there’s no difficulty enjoying him at third when wanted, which means that Romy Gonzalez and Nick Sogard will solely get a couple of enjoying time crumbs right here.

Due to the presence of Adley Rutschman, Gunnar Henderson, and Jackson Holliday, Jordan Westburg progressed by way of the Orioles system with surprisingly little hoopla for a former first-round decide. However he at all times hit within the minors, and he was referred to as up in June 2023 with Adam Frazier and Jorge Mateo flagging. Westburg’s .260/.311/.404 rookie line wasn’t eye-popping, however it ensured that he made the Opening Day roster in 2024, and he solidified his place by bursting out of the gates final April, ending the month with an .880 OPS. When Holliday was optioned again to the minors, Westburg performed a bunch of second base as properly. He’s projected to see a whole lot of time there once more in 2025 because the backup to Holliday, and he’ll seemingly be the starter if the Orioles are conservative about utilizing the latter towards left-handed pitchers.

Ramón Urías has been a precious utility infielder the previous few years, a task he’ll proceed to fill in 2025. He’s had relatively risky left/proper splits, however he must be greater than able to being a “form of” platoonmate for Holliday, with Westburg shifting to second base and Urías enjoying third towards lefties. It’s additionally potential that Holliday and Urías find yourself in a extra conventional platoon scenario at second, leaving Westburg the unique third baseman, however the Orioles have been a bit opaque about what the plan is.

ZiPS nonetheless thinks Coby Mayo can credibly play third, however it’s largely a moot difficulty with Westburg and Urías firmly established on the depth chart forward of him. Mayo’s shot at extra common enjoying time would possibly are available one other group, which is a minimum of a risk if Baltimore tries to commerce for a beginning pitcher sooner or later this season. Mayo expressed his frustrations in regards to the scenario after being optioned to Triple-A Norfolk on Tuesday. And it’s not onerous to see the place he’s coming from — after beating up on Triple-A pitchers for greater than a yr, there nonetheless isn’t an apparent path to getting him important time in Baltimore.

I’m glad to see Junior Caminero right here, largely as a result of I’ve at all times been a fan of gamers who I can use for brand spanking new lyrics to the Canyonero tune from The Simpsons. Whereas his 119 wRC+ in Triple-A and 105 wRC+ within the majors final yr gained’t make your eyes to come out of their sockets, these are spectacular outcomes for a 20-year-old; most gamers that age are simply reaching Excessive-A or are attempting to cross the Double-A threshold. Whereas Caminero has performed some shortstop, it’s been obvious for some time that Carson Williams is the long run there and Ha-Seong Kim the current, a minimum of when the latter’s shoulder has healed. The projection programs disagree about Caminero, and sadly, I’ve to aspect with Steamer and OOPSY over ZiPS on this one. Whereas nonetheless projecting a really strong marketing campaign for Caminero, I feel ZiPS is underselling his potential energy upside.

The speedy José Caballero is the backup. He has been adequate to be value 3.8 WAR within the majors at simply over a full season’s value of plate appearances, however Caminero must have a really lengthy leash right here. Nonetheless, Caballero’s talents imply the Rays gained’t be incentivized to play Christopher Morel at third and avert their eyes when he’s on the sphere. Curtis Mead might be Most worthy as a 3rd baseman, however he seems to be the odd man out, and I anticipate that he’s a prime candidate to be traded elsewhere ought to the Rays want to accumulate additional assist this yr.

Re-signing Pete Alonso to play first base restored the established order ante at third for the Mets, with Mark Vientos returning to the scene of his breakout 2024 season. When you ranked the gamers whose widespread notion across the league jumped probably the most final yr, Vientos would seemingly be at or close to the highest of your checklist, as he efficiently worn out the recollections of his 68 wRC+ in 2023 with a .266/.322/.516 triple-slash, 133 wRC+, and 27 round-trippers. And whereas Vientos won’t have wowed with the leather-based, he has a minimum of established that he’s not an unplayable catastrophe at third.

You may be tempted to imagine that 2024 is now Vientos’ established degree of play, however “final yr” is a really poor projection system. His efficiency from 2023 nonetheless issues, and the projections are all largely hedging their bets till we see extra from him. Regardless of the pc pouring some chilly water on expectations, Vientos remains to be forecast to be strong sufficient to maintain the Mets within the prime third of the league.

So long as Vientos is wholesome and a minimum of in the identical galaxy as final yr production-wise, there’ll solely be scraps accessible at third base. Any of Jeff McNeil, Brett Baty, and Ronny Mauricio might catch an odd begin right here or there. A major damage most likely leaves Baty as the following choice, as he would have been if Alonso had signed elsewhere and Vientos had moved to first base.

The Twins’ third base rank isn’t a lot a query of efficiency as it’s one in every of well being, and that query is: Can Royce Lewis keep wholesome sufficient to get the 500-plus plate appearances he’s projected to on our Depth Charts? The final time Lewis performed even 100 video games in a season was means again in 2019. However whether or not you favor the mildly optimistic ZiPS projection (111 wRC+) or the sunnier OOPSY prediction (126 wRC+), a wholesome Lewis can hit, and he gained’t give these runs again on protection. Hopefully, his hamstring damage, which is able to hold him out of the Opening Day lineup, isn’t an inauspicious signal of issues to come back.

Third base is deep, nonetheless, and the outlook turns into foggier if Lewis as soon as once more struggles to get greater than 200-300 plate appearances. Willi Castro has been shockingly good the final couple of years, however the Twins have used him everywhere in the diamond, and it was Jose Miranda who bought the lion’s share of the non-Lewis time at third final yr. If the Twins find yourself with a whole lot of Miranda and Brooks Lee, their final place right here may be 10-15 spots decrease than it’s now.

Among the protection of Nolan Arenado’s decline would possibly go away you with the impression that he was a replacement-level participant in 2023 and 2024, and bears a big share of the accountability for the Cardinals’ lackluster leads to these two seasons. However whereas it’s true that he’s displaying indicators of slowing down, particularly with the bat, he’s nonetheless a solidly above-average participant total, and he hasn’t missed even 20 video games in a season since 2014. He’s been a bit underneath his profession numbers by wRC+ the final two seasons (104 vs. 118), however that’s completely regular for a participant getting into his mid-30s. Arenado’s crime seems to be not repeating his 7.2 WAR, 149 wRC+ 2022 marketing campaign, however that was by no means an affordable expectation.

For the reason that Cardinals haven’t been in a position to swing a commerce that Arenado would approve of, they’ll must undergo the indignity of getting a B+ third baseman, who’s placing collectively a robust Corridor of Fame argument, on their roster. Quelle horreur!

With no questions as to his sturdiness, we’re solely projecting a handful of scattered appearances by the opposite gamers right here. Ought to an damage come up, I think Brendan Donovan would be the most certainly recipient of the enjoying time, and must acquit himself properly, with the Playing cards seemingly utilizing Thomas Saggese and Nolan Gorman to take over Donovan’s different duties at second, left discipline, and designated hitter.

Within the first half of final season, Alec Bohm seemed like he had silenced any doubts about whether or not he’s Philadelphia’s long-term answer on the sizzling nook. He posted a 128 wRC+, hit 11 residence runs, and made the All-Star workforce. However then a hand damage knocked him out in early September (his bat had began to swoon earlier than that), and he was terrible after returning, together with a 1-for-13 efficiency in Philly’s fast playoff exit. Bohm was a frequent subject of commerce rumors this winter, however nothing got here out of it, and it might take greater than his unhealthy end to the season to bench him.

Bohm additionally put up his greatest defensive season to this point, with a FRV of three runs above common. It’s not only a Statcast outlier both, as DRS, which beforehand completely hated Bohm, to the tune of getting him at -10 runs or worse every of the previous few years, pegged him as common at third base. As Philadelphia’s core ages, Bohm’s presence will proceed to tackle better significance.

It’d shock you to study that after 4 seasons as an all-purpose position participant, Edmundo Sosa has been value 3.5 WAR per 600 plate appearances within the majors. Barring damage, Sosa gained’t get a ton of time right here, however he’s a superb Plan B.

Yearly, somebody predicts the demise of Max Muncy, however to this point, he’s principally proven no decline on the plate when wholesome. Decline will come finally, in fact, as a result of time is the one undefeated entity within the universe, however there’s no explicit motive to assume 2025 is the yr. Muncy missed three months final season with an indirect damage and a displaced rib, however he put up a .925 OPS after returning in mid-August, placing to relaxation any issues that the damage would sap his manufacturing. He stays a middling defensive participant at third, however a minimum of he’s holding regular, as a transfer to first base or designated hitter is impractical on a workforce that employs Freddie Freeman and Shohei Ohtani.

If Muncy struggles with accidents once more or simply wants time without work, Chris Taylor and Enrique Hernández can be found in reserve. The hope is that Taylor’s drop-off final yr was a BABIP mirage and that Hernández will assist out towards the occasional lefty. It’s value noting, nonetheless, that Hernández’s platoon splits have shrunk in recent times, and earlier than his profitable return to the Dodgers, he had struggled the earlier season-plus with the Crimson Sox.

Miguel Rojas and David Bote are emergency choices, although they’ll seemingly see little or no enjoying time right here, if any. Alex Freeland may very well be the eventual successor at third base if he continues to impress and is unable to push Mookie Betts off shortstop, however he’s unlikely to be a menace to Muncy’s enjoying time this season.

Who’s Toronto’s third baseman? I’m unsure the Blue Jays even know for positive proper now. On the prime of the heap, we have now Ernie Clement, in some ways the least formidable choice right here. Clement was completely ample in 2024, however he didn’t significantly excel at anybody facet of the job. He has some energy and a few protection and steals the occasional base, a mixture that screams stopgap participant. Additionally working towards him is the truth that he’s the oldest of the six choices listed right here, and doesn’t have an exploitable platoon break up that the Jays might use situationally.

It’s almost put-up-or-shut-up time for Orelvis Martinez, who has been a prospect seemingly for eternally, and was suspended for PED use for a big chunk of 2024. He’s nonetheless simply 23, nonetheless, and hit properly in Triple-A final yr; he actually has the best upside of anybody right here.

Will Wagner is an attention-grabbing bat and has good on-base expertise, however he’s more likely to see important enjoying time at different positions, particularly DH. I’m nonetheless a fan of Addison Barger, however he didn’t hit in any respect within the majors final season; the Jays, who intend to contend, can have a tough time giving full-time at-bats to him or Davis Schneider. Vladito might even see a little bit of time at third, relying on how issues shake out.

After enjoying in 122 video games in 2023, it appeared that Josh Jung had lastly gotten off the damage schneid that price him a lot of 2022 (torn labrum) and a very good chunk of 2021 (stress fracture). Alas, it was to not be. 4 video games into the season, he swung at an errant Phil Maton pitch that linked together with his wrist as an alternative of his bat. The fracture price him almost 4 months, and Jung struggled upon his return, hitting simply .248/.278/.366 with middling protection the remainder of the way in which.

Jung’s nonetheless younger, so the projection programs aren’t overly involved about one other largely misplaced season, anticipating him to be about league-average total at third base in 2025. There’s nonetheless upside right here if he stays wholesome, and Jung might very properly be a 3-4 WAR participant this yr, however some warning is warranted.

Nonetheless, it wasn’t the lack of Jung that dropped the Rangers from World Collection champs to 78-84, as he was greater than capably changed by Josh Smith, who served as the first third baseman with Jung on the shelf (when he wasn’t chipping in for Corey Seager at shortstop). He’s most likely each bit pretty much as good an choice at third as Jung, and even barely higher for those who imagine ZiPS, so the Rangers ought to stay assured right here if he’s pressured into motion once more.

Whereas the Cubs talked with Alex Bregman earlier than he signed with the Crimson Sox, the truth that the workforce did little else to pursue viable alternate options at third should mirror some confidence in Matt Shaw, a 2023 first-round decide. Shaw shot by way of the minors fairly rapidly, hitting in every single place he performed, and his conversion from the center infield to 3rd base in 2024 seems to have been fairly profitable. The projection programs all see his bat as adequate to make him a mid-tier starter at third base in his rookie yr. It’s best to keep away from the inevitable comparisons to Kris Bryant a decade go, as Shaw doesn’t have that sort of energy and wasn’t very aggressive swinging at good pitches, a minimum of after he reached Triple-A (60% zone swing price vs. 69% massive league common), however his prospect report notes that, “he’s monitoring like an above-average on a regular basis participant and foundational younger expertise.”

Gage Workman is a terrific defensive participant, however he’s a pure backup until one thing goes terribly flawed. ZiPS gauged (sorry) Workman as among the best defensive third basemen within the minors final yr, and infield protection has been a precedence for the Cubs in latest seasons. Whereas he’s not anticipated to offer a lot on the plate, a 140 wRC+ at Double-A final yr demonstrates that there’s a minimum of some risk he gained’t be an entire zero offensively.

Justin Turner was introduced in as a veteran bat off the bench, however at 40 years outdated and two years faraway from critical enjoying time at third base, it’s onerous to see him getting a lot time right here apart from as an emergency choice.

A shortstop by commerce, Maikel Garcia suffers the misfortune of enjoying the identical place as Bobby Witt Jr. The Royals shifted him to 3rd base in 2023 and Garcia performed strong protection, as you would possibly anticipate from a reliable shortstop. The questions right here concern his offensive output. He confirmed some promise in 2023, and hit sufficient to be an average-ish starter at third, however his batting common cratered in 2024, a harmful end result for a hitter who has nearly no energy to fall again on.

One factor that Garcia has struggled with is translating his on-base expertise from the minors to the massive leagues. He’s a really disciplined hitter and makes good contact, however his strategy borders on passive. Garcia lays off the unhealthy stuff, however he additionally lets a whole lot of the great things go by, and he will get into a whole lot of 0-1 counts as a result of no one fears getting punished by him. Lengthy-term, Garcia’s greatest position could also be as a supersub kind.

Jonathan India is probably the most attention-grabbing different right here, however the Royals don’t appear inclined to make use of him to push Garcia into the outfield. Nick Loftin could present a bit extra offense, however he lacks Garcia’s glove, and Cavan Biggio’s early promise is a good distance off within the rear view mirror.

4 years in the past, it seemed like Eugenio Suárez was on the verge of washing out of the majors after a mediocre 2020 season and a downright dreadful 2021. However a commerce to the Mariners gave his profession a formidable second wind, as his bat recovered (a 117 wRC+ in Seattle over two seasons) and he displayed some strong protection. Arizona picked up his contract from the Mariners and Suárez responded together with his third straight 3-WAR season.

So why is Suárez so low? At 33 (34 in July), he’s among the many oldest starters on the sizzling nook, and regardless that third base solely boasts a couple of real MVP varieties, it’s typically a deep place. There’s actually some danger of a collapse, excess of with an equal 27-year-old, and it seemed for a time like that’s what was taking place final yr, as Suárez was dreadful within the first half (.668 OPS) earlier than out of the blue transmogrifing into an MVP kind within the second (.942 OPS).

Jordan Lawlar is a candidate to finally exchange Suárez, and whereas Lawlar is a shortstop, the workforce is dedicated to Geraldo Perdomo there, and Ketel Marte goes to be even more durable to supplant over at second. However Lawlar’s short-term job isn’t displacing a starter however relatively getting again to the place he was earlier than a 2024 ruined by thumb and hamstring accidents.

Nineteen won’t sound so good, however as I write this, third base is one in every of solely two positions the place the projections don’t put the White Sox within the backside 5. Miguel Vargas will get the primary probability on the job after being picked up final July within the Michael Kopech/Erick Fedde three-team commerce. He was completely dreadful for the Sox final yr, with a wRC+ of 16, a quantity that appears extra like a calculation bug than an precise efficiency by a serious league hitter. His historical past within the majors isn’t prolonged, however his 82 wRC+ with the Dodgers, whereas hardly spectacular, is much better, and his minor league document was a strong. Now, there are very actual questions on who the actual Vargas is, however the Sox are a positive place to spend time discovering out; there’s nothing that he can do in 2025 that may significant enhance or worsen the workforce’s probabilities of making the playoffs.

If Vargas struggles an excessive amount of, anticipate to see a whole lot of Josh Rojas. I’m unsure that’s a very good factor, nonetheless; Rojas is a serviceable position participant, however he isn’t younger and doesn’t have a future in Chicago.

Bryan Ramos has been on the workforce’s prospect checklist for fairly some time now, however he struggled in 2024, and desires to point out he can hit Triple-A pitching earlier than he will get a second prolonged strive within the majors. Chase Meidroth, who was picked up within the Garrett Crochet commerce, is a ZiPS favourite, however he might very properly begin at second base or shortstop, relying how the White Sox look popping out of camp.

I wouldn’t be shocked to see the Angels get much more out of third base than this if fortune smiles upon them. Sadly, the fates have proven Yoán Moncada little favor over the course of his profession; after tallying 9.8 WAR from 2019 to 2021, he suffered a collection of accidents that led to him having to take a pillow contract with the Angels this winter. Moncada’s solely 29 (30 in Could), and a 5-WAR participant should still be hiding in there someplace, however after three disappointing seasons, you may’t simply cross your fingers and anticipate his well being and manufacturing to handle itself.

Luis Rengifo has developed right into a strong Swiss Military Knife of a participant who can play respectable — although removed from spectacular — protection at most positions. He’s even turn out to be extra of an offensive power than was anticipated when he was a prospect, with a .273/.323/.431 line over the past three seasons. Like Moncada, Rengifo is a free agent after this season, and will appeal to important curiosity from different groups later this yr.

If Moncada proves ineffective or must spend time on the IL, the addition of Kevin Newman to again up the center infield ought to release Rengifo to play third base extra usually. J.D. Davis is an choice as properly, although he’s solely on the workforce as a non-roster invitee.

Contemplating that the incumbent starter, Ke’Bryan Hayes, hit .233/.283/.290 final yr, a middling rating ought to be a supply of aid relatively than indigestion for the Pirates. The projection programs all see Hayes recovering sufficient of his misplaced offense to get again to his profession averages, which when mixed together with his potential Gold Glove-worthy protection at third, make him a viable starter. Nonetheless, sufficient time has handed since his spectacular 2020 debut that we are able to most likely shut the door on the potential of a giant offensive breakout.

Jared Triolo was one of many massive surprises of 2023. He was an on-base machine in his rookie marketing campaign, ending with a .388 OBP in 54 video games. Utility-guy-with-good-plate-discipline-having-a-hot-six-weeks was at all times extra seemingly than him being the reincarnation of Eddie Joost, and he fell off to a 72 wRC+ after opening 2024 because the beginning second baseman. Nonetheless, as an especially versatile position participant who can draw a stroll, he has his makes use of.

Neither of Adam Frazier or Nick Yorke has performed a lot third professionally, however they may a minimum of theoretically get a while there, relying on who makes the roster subsequent week. Isiah Kiner-Falefa has performed extra third base than the others, however he’s presently the workforce’s beginning shortstop, for causes I’m unsure I comprehend.

New York’s third base combine is likely one of the more durable ones to foretell. DJ LeMahieu seems to have first dibs on the place on the energy of his historical past with the Yankees and wage, however he’s presently out with a calf pressure. Past the damage, there’s an actual query whether or not LeMahieu has something left in him at age 36 and coming off an injury-filled .204/.269/.259, -0.5 WAR season.

If the Yankees haven’t proven a lot urgency about transferring on from LeMahieu, neither Oswaldo Cabrera nor Oswald Peraza has completed a lot this spring to actually power the workforce’s hand. Peraza, as soon as a reliable shortstop prospect earlier than Anthony Volpe’s emergence, seemingly has extra upside remaining than Cabrera, and he’s out of choices. However Cabrera has had the higher spring, and the very fact stays that the Yankees favored him sufficient to provide him a whole lot of begins at third final yr.

Pablo Reyes might be a greater offensive participant than he’s proven within the majors, however he’s too far again within the pecking order to have a lot of an opportunity in New York. Jorbit Vivas is in the identical boat; if he will get 300 plate appearances for the Yankees in 2025, one thing has most likely gone terribly flawed for the Bombers.

The anticipated timeshare of Gio Urshela and Luis Urías represents the uncommon platoon involving two hitters who bat from the identical aspect of the plate. Urías, a February signing in what was a surprisingly busy offseason for the Athletics, has at all times been efficient at beating up on southpaws. Urshela isn’t the perfect platoon-mate, given his small long-term handedness differential (4 factors of OPS for his profession), however he’s usually extra acceptable towards righties than Urías is.

U2 isn’t in Sacramento to provide the A’s elite manufacturing, however relatively to offer them with roughly league-average manufacturing at an affordable price. At two mixed wins within the projections and a $3.3 million wage between them, that’s exactly what we anticipate the A’s to get.

Between Max Schuemann and Darell Hernaiz, the previous is extra more likely to be on the roster as a utility participant who will seemingly get far fewer than the 459 plate appearances he obtained in 2024. At age 23, it’s higher to have Hernaiz getting common enjoying time with Triple-A Las Vegas than spend a whole lot of time sitting on the bench in Sacramento. Probably the most attention-grabbing participant right here may be the “different” Max Muncy, who seems hopelessly blocked at shortstop by Jacob Wilson. If his energy continues to develop, I wouldn’t be shocked to see him sweep everybody forward of him off the depth chart in 2026, and even late this yr.

Meh.

When the Mariners re-signed Jorge Polanco to a one-year contract again in February, my colleague Michael Rosen’s piece in regards to the deal was headlined “Mariners Signal Jorge Polanco, Condemn Themselves to Competence.” I don’t assume there’s a greater solution to describe the transaction. Polanco’s .213/.296/.355 line could look a bit worse than it truly was due to T-Cellular Park, however that doesn’t imply it was truly good, even for those who give him a whole lot of additional leeway due to his knee and hamstring accidents.

We predict Polanco to comfortably beat his 0.3 WAR from final yr, however that is shockingly unambitious for a workforce with an actual probability to win the AL West. Polanco will most likely play higher protection at third than he did at second the previous few years, however that’s merely not sufficient.

No person on the roster is more likely to be an apparent improve on Polanco, both. At 37, Donovan Solano is a utility man within the twilight of his profession, not somebody who can push Polanco, and Dylan Moore will seemingly be over at second base more often than not. Given the dearth of upside, I’d have favored to have seen the Mariners a minimum of strive one thing daring. Give Austin Shenton a couple of months to try to show his bat can play within the majors. Or simply say “to hell with it” and stick Ben Williamson there — a minimum of you understand the protection might be good.

Getting into the fourth yr of a six-year, $70 million contract extension, Ryan McMahon has an iron grip on the third base job in Colorado. McMahon made his first All-Star Sport in 2024, on the again of a legitimately wonderful .272/.353/.447, 2.2 WAR first-half efficiency. Nevertheless, he struggled through the second half, enjoying beneath alternative degree for the final two and a half months of the season.

McMahon’s glove at third base is great, sufficient to marvel if he may need been Most worthy as a second baseman, if the workforce had had the abdomen to go away him there. On the sizzling nook, his offense is run-of-the-mill, with out a lot there past his average energy. He’s a poor contact hitter within the park that the majority rewards placing the ball in play, and among the many 34 third basemen with a minimum of 2,000 plate appearances since McMahon’s debut, his 71.8% contact price is the third worst, forward of solely Miguel Sanó and J.D. Davis. A .240 batting common is widespread nowadays, however it shouldn’t be for a very good hitter at Coors Subject provided that it performs as way more of a batting common park than a house run park nowadays.

There’s no menace to McMahon’s beginning job in 2025. Kyle Karros would possibly pose a menace sometime if he hits within the excessive minors, however as evidenced by him not showing on this chart, that’s a couple of years away at minimal.

For a stretch this winter, it seemed like Alex Bregman may be Detroit’s subsequent third baseman, however he signed with the Crimson Sox, leaving the Tigers with the identical choices they’d final yr. Jace Jung was the plain alternative right here for those who imagine the metrics, however the Tigers have appeared underwhelmed by his protection, and he had a horrible spring, leading to him being optioned to Triple-A. Whereas Jung will get one other probability and possibly has probably the most upside of the seemingly third base candidates, he’s not getting that shot instantly.

Jung’s demotion makes this an space of uncertainty for the Tigers. Assuming he does get again to the majors this yr, he’s more likely to break up time with one of many a number of position gamers the workforce has used at third base. Andy Ibáñez is a pure platoon associate for Jung, with a .799 profession OPS within the majors towards lefties. With Jung within the minors for now, I’d anticipate Ibáñez to be paired with somebody higher towards righties. Zach McKinstry is the obvious candidate, however the Tigers shuttle him everywhere in the diamond, and so they is probably not inquisitive about holding him pinned down as a platoon third baseman.

The Tigers have often used Javier Báez at third the final couple of weeks, so he’s an choice to participate of the job, as is Trey Sweeney relying on how the defensive configurations shake out. Additional complicating issues, Matt Vierling might see a while right here when he’s again from a shoulder pressure, a minimum of as soon as Parker Meadows has returned from his damage.

TLDR: I dunno!

Among the many higher degree prospects, Hao-Yu Lee is an attention-grabbing choice and has been getting reps at third base in spring coaching. Given a 141 wRC+ as a 21-year-old in Double-A ball final yr, he actually deserves watching. If Jung doesn’t progress, not one of the varied position gamers are seemingly long-term options at third base, which means that Lee might see an actual path to enjoying time quickly. However let’s not get too far forward of ourselves.

Connor Norby’s been on the sting of prospect lists for some time now, however was he hopeless blocked in Baltimore by the myriad higher choices the O’s possessed. Norby bought important enjoying time after heading to Miami within the Trevor Rogers commerce, and with a .247/.315/.445 line with seven homers in 36 video games, he did sufficient to make him the plain first alternative for the offense-starved Marlins. Norby’s protection was decidedly unimpressive, however provided that he was an ample second baseman and hadn’t performed third base often since school, I wouldn’t fear an excessive amount of simply but. Norby’s rating suffers from the truth that third base is a deep place in the intervening time.

Graham Pauley was having a second a couple of years in the past after a breakout 2023 season within the minors, however he crashed again to earth final yr after his Triple-A debut. As such, expectations have been dampened significantly, and he’s primarily Norby’s backup by default.

Eric Wagaman’s a mildly attention-grabbing minor leaguer given his energy, however he’s too outdated to be thought-about a critical prospect. He snuck in an honest sized cup of espresso from the Angels final yr, lengthy after anybody was watching the workforce, however his position might be to attempt to present he can hit in Triple-A, and probably displace Pauley as Norby’s backup someday this season.

A big share of the place gamers on Cincinnati’s 40-man roster look like middling third basemen, however the workforce has but to determine learn how to amalgamize all of them right into a single good one. New supervisor Terry Francona has been hinting at a Jeimer Candelario/Gavin Lux platoon at third base, although not essentially a strict one. Lux has struggled towards lefties within the majors, however ZiPS tasks him with a .267/.344/.410 line towards righties, and it might be the position that most accurately fits him given the entrenched center infield of Elly De La Cruz and Matt McLain.

I used to be skeptical of the Candelario signing, however he was even worse than I imagined, hitting .225/.279/.429 whereas shuttling between third base, first base, and designated hitter. If Candelario struggles or finally ends up enjoying extra elsewhere, Santiago Espinal could also be a extra orthodox platoon-mate for Lux; he has a .777 profession OPS within the majors towards lefties.

Noelvi Marte’s far too younger to surrender on, however 2024 was an unmitigated catastrophe. He began off with an 80-game suspension for a constructive take a look at for Boldenone, after which after being given an open shot on the massive league third base job when he returned, he proceeded to place up a .549 OPS in 66 video games. He might very properly work his means into enjoying time later within the season and even seize the job sometime, however first he’s going to wish to re-establish his credentials at Triple-A Louisville.

The Brewers bought surprisingly good manufacturing out of third base final yr due to the emergence of Joey Ortiz, who they acquired from the Orioles within the Corbin Burnes commerce. However Ortiz has been moved again to his unique place, shortstop, to exchange the departed Willy Adames, and Milwaukee didn’t search a alternative this winter.

Whereas thrift little doubt performed a big position in Milwaukee’s considering right here, some perception in Oliver Dunn’s upside was most likely part of the choice to provide him an opportunity to be the starter. Dunn’s prospect days are behind him, however he might nonetheless emerge as a late bloomer. He has been hindered by the lack of the vast majority of three developmental seasons because of the cancellation of the minor league season in 2020, hamstring and stomach accidents in 2022, and a again damage that prematurely ended his 2024, however in a wholesome season in 2023, he hit 21 homers and put up a 148 wRC+ for Double-A Studying. A knock towards Dunn being a Ken Phelps All-Star is the truth that he was a 25-year-old in Double-A; his 104 plate appearances in Milwaukee final yr have been additionally unimpressive, as was his 69% contact price.

Center infielder Caleb Durbin is subsequent up within the queue. He’s a pair years youthful than Dunn and may draw some walks, however he additionally lacks Dunn’s energy. Vinny Capra and Andrew Monasterio stay within the combine, as does Tyler Black, however the Brewers clearly take a look at him as extra of a 1B/DH kind than a 3rd baseman.

The Washington Nationals are forming a formidable offensive nucleus, such you can begin to see the contours of what a return to competition would possibly appear like. That basis doesn’t embody a 3rd baseman, nonetheless, and Washington seems to be going with a pure stopgap choice in veteran Paul DeJong. DeJong led White Sox hitters in WAR final yr, although that most likely says extra in regards to the 41-win Sox than DeJong. DeJong performs good protection and may run into sufficient pitches to place up some strong residence run totals, however he does little else. There aren’t many gamers who push a workforce in the direction of the playoffs with a .269 on-base share, and DeJong just isn’t one of many uncommon exceptions.

José Tena stays within the image, however a poor spring seems to have put him firmly behind DeJong when it comes to enjoying time. Whereas he hit properly within the excessive minors for the Guardians, as soon as he bought to Cleveland, neither his bat nor his glove made a convincing case for him getting the full-time job at third. Nonetheless, if the Nats fall out of the Wild Card race, it might make way more sense for him to get enjoying time over DeJong. Trey Lipscomb was initially anticipated to battle with Tena for the job at third, however his lack of offensive upside makes him a much less attention-grabbing choice.

Amed Rosario is on the workforce because the veteran emergency choice, and whereas ZiPS likes Brady Home’s protection, not one of the projections assume he’s as much as the duty of hitting sufficient to be a viable starter at third.