Final week, I wrote about how TGL—a simulator league that can characteristic PGA Tour gamers—has some area to seize the eye of golf followers in 2025.
Working from January by March, TGL has so much going for it. That features a priceless time slot on ESPN and the very fact Tiger Woods goes to be a constant participant within the league regardless of his lack of aggressive involvement in Tour golf at this stage in his profession.
The format and expertise, which you’ll be able to examine right here, can be intriguing. There shall be matches that includes three gamers on every four-man roster, ultimately resulting in a workforce playoff. That construction may additionally make for fertile playing floor, an area golf hasn’t correctly explored thus far.
My opinion on TGL is that it could possibly be a fantastic factor for golf. The TV product must be higher than a conventional broadcast and being on ESPN is a large enhance to drawn in informal viewers. Will it revolutionize golf? I’m not keen to go there however I’m optimistic that it could possibly be very useful for a sport caught within the mud.
Nonetheless, there are a couple of regarding features of TGL that would maintain it again. If it had been to battle, these parts would seemingly be the culprits.
In no explicit order, listed here are 5 causes TGL won’t resonate with individuals.
1. The groups don’t have any that means
This one is a head-scratcher, particularly after LIV simply made the very same mistake.
The TGL groups are utterly arbitrary. Gamers are representing main cities however many of the gamers will not be from that metropolis. The foursomes don’t have any relationship to one another past the truth that everyone seems to be a Tour participant. Why is every participant on every workforce? No one is aware of.
And there gained’t be house or street video games; every part takes place at SoFi Enviornment in South Florida. So why ought to these gamers be representing a metropolis within the first place?
One among LIV’s downfalls is that its groups got here collectively arbitrarily. Gamers are traded randomly. There isn’t a construction for why a participant must be on a sure workforce.
Why wouldn’t TGL set it up otherwise? Take your six hottest gamers and have them be the workforce captains who draft their very own guys: Staff Tiger, Staff McIlroy, Staff Morikawa, and many others.
Now we’ve got context. Staff Tiger has Justin Thomas on it as a result of Tiger drafted him as a substitute of Max Homa. Then what if the final man picked performs nicely? What if the primary man picked performs poorly?
In Season Two, the worst workforce may draft a participant who isn’t competing in TGL—perhaps somebody who had a breakout 12 months on Tour. Expertise comes out and in. There may be some intrigue over who retains their spot and who stays.
The way in which TGL set it up, there may be little purpose to root for a selected workforce. It’s not region-specific as a result of the gamers don’t determine with that workforce within the first place. It’s not draft-specific. We don’t know why it got here collectively that approach. Why ought to I root for Tom Kim on Tiger’s workforce? The one purpose is that he’s on the workforce for causes no person understands.
2. The gamers won’t have the persona to make it entertaining
The premise of TGL is that we’ll have full entry to the gamers all through every match. They are going to be mic’d up and (hopefully) jawing backwards and forwards to make a extra casual and interactive environment.
That’s what we commonly see with YouTube golf as nice personalities shine by the digital camera. Individuals are watching to be entertained by jokes as they (generally) get pleasure from good golf together with it.
However what about these gamers will make them entertaining?
All of those guys play severe golf for a dwelling. They prepare to be the perfect gamers on the planet. This isn’t Fats Perez cracking jokes on display screen—it’s golfers who’re programmed to pay attention and win.
Are any of those gamers humorous? Will it come by on display screen? It’s robust for skilled athletes to rapidly activate the allure in entrance of a digital camera for 2 hours and there apparently gained’t be a lot in the way in which of coloration commentating because the match is occurring.
There must be some trash speak and lightheartedness to this sport. It’s not actual golf and there may be nothing significant at stake. We must be listening to from the gamers about what sort of shot they’re making an attempt to hit and get their on the spot reactions. The gamers have to be much less robotic and extra expressive.
Having Scott Van Pelt and Marty Smith interviewing the gamers is promising—these guys are humorous and witty—however will the gamers match that vitality every week?
I’m skeptical about that which naturally leads me to the following level.
3. TGL could possibly be far more severe than needed
Look, TGL will discover success if it veers extra into the absurd and comedic. This could look completely nothing like Tour golf or exhibition golf. It must be the alternative of conventional.
There’s a construction to the competitors, which is okay, however we’d like greater than that. This must enterprise extra into Saturday Night time Stay territory—slapstick comedy with barbs going backwards and forwards. And when it’s not humorous, it must be guys making an attempt to tug off loopy photographs and reacting expressively.
Kevin Kisner is a full-time NBC announcer and he’s taking part in on this league. This isn’t a severe competitors and shouldn’t be handled like one.
The winner of this league doesn’t get something significant. It’s not necessary to win. That is purely for leisure.
It could be good to keep away from treating this like each shot issues. That is the place LIV bought caught—it’s too just like regular golf. It’s only a worse model of the conventional Tour.
We should always watch the primary night time of TGL and agree that it’s wildly completely different from the staid Tour vibe. I’m cynical about them getting this proper, largely as a result of …
4. The individuals operating this are part of the institution
Who’s behind TGL?
TGL is being produced by TMRW Sports activities, an organization based by Woods, McIlroy and NBC Sports activities government Mike McCarley. Nevertheless it’s additionally being being produced in partnership with the PGA Tour.
Woods and McIlroy are the frontmen however this largely comes all the way down to McCarley and others within the established golf world. McCarley led the NBC Sports activities golf efforts from 2011-2021 and initiatives just like the subscription-based GolfPass and tee-time service GolfNow.
Yeah, I don’t really feel nice about that.
NBC’s golf protection has been a complete catastrophe for a very long time. Golf Channel, owned by NBC, is in the bathroom— simply have a look at their lack of authentic programming and downright terrible morning exhibits. I’m undecided who makes use of GolfPass until you commonly e-book tee instances on GolfNow and wish reductions (in case you do subscribe, let me know why you prefer it).
Add within the Tour’s affect right here and I’m not precisely anticipating this to be “Contained in the NBA” from an execution standpoint. It most likely gained’t be practically as edgy or humorous because it must be.
If the individuals behind TGL had been whole outsiders to the sport, I’d really feel so much higher about how the telecast shall be reimagined. I’d additionally really feel higher in regards to the TV product if the normal broadcast was charming, which is clearly not the case.
Apologies for being scarred by the previous few years however I’ve hassle trusting any professional golf decision-maker at this level.
5. Is that this simply one other money redistribution mechanism?
Ah, in fact, we’ve got to speak about cash.
Is the TGL only a thinly veiled try and get the highest Tour gamers more cash? Is it only a comfort prize to pump up their wallets after they didn’t get the ludicrous sums supplied by LIV?
Truthfully, I feel the reply is sure. At the very least partially. The Tour has been frantically scrambling to ensure its expertise stays in-house and I’m assuming TGL is one other play to fulfill gamers financially.
That worries me on a pair fronts. Are the gamers right here to make a real entertaining product for the followers? Or are they right here to money checks and transfer on with their lives?
The gamers are going to be accountable for whether or not this works or not. They should activate the allure and act like they’re taking part in with their buddies again house.
In the event that they aren’t invested in that, TGL may crash and burn.
Do you assume the TGL shall be profitable? Let me know beneath within the feedback.
Prime Picture Caption: Tiger Woods and Rory McIlroy are driving forces behind TGL. (GETTY IMAGES/Christian Petersen)
The put up 5 Causes TGL May Fall Flat appeared first on MyGolfSpy.
