Earlier immediately, we took a more in-depth have a look at the Miami Dolphins’ 2025 draft grade from ESPN’s Mel Kiper, Jr. Now, we scan the online for the opposite NFL Draft grades 2025 choices which can be on the market. What’s being mentioned concerning the Dolphins’ efficiency all through the three-day draft? What do the analysts consider Miami’s eight picks?
Under you will see that the positioning, writer, and hyperlink to every grade, together with any evaluation the positioning gives. You may try every of the websites for the remainder of their grades for all 31 different groups.
Common Grade: C+ (calculated 2.4 GPA)
Related Press – Rob Maaddi
Grade: B+
DT Kenneth Grant (13) fills a direct want. So does G Jonah Savaiinaea (37). DT Jordan Phillips (143), CB Jason Marshall Jr. and S Dante Dealer Jr. (155) replenish the defensive facet. QB Quinn Ewers (231) is powerful worth within the seventh spherical.
Bleacher Report – Kristopher Knox
Grade: C
The Miami Dolphins kicked off their 2025 draft class with a little bit of a attain. Whereas Michigan defensive deal with Kenneth Grant possesses sufficient upside to justify stepping into Spherical 1—he was the Twenty sixth-ranked prospect on the ultimate B/R board—he’s extremely unlikely to be an every-down contributor.
At 6’4” and 331 kilos, Grant tasks as extra of a space-eating nostril deal with than a flexible three-down defender. Miami has wanted line of defense assist since dropping Christian Wilkins in 2024 free company, however there was higher worth to be discovered at No. 13.
Defensive lineman Walter Nolen, tight finish Tyler Warren and edge-rusher Shemar Stewart have been all rated greater than Grant by the Bleacher Report Scouting Division and drafted after him on opening evening.
Miami continued to be aggressive in addressing wants on Day 2. Following a commerce with the Raiders, the Dolphins grabbed themselves a guard in Arizona’s Jonah Savaiinaea.
Savaiinaea can present depth at deal with however will probably make a extra rapid affect if the Dolphins play him inside.
“Savaiinaea is greatest suited inside at guard within the NFL, the place his starter-level dimension, sq. energy, and preliminary quicks can earn him a beginning function early in his rookie contract,” Brandon Thorn of the B/R Scouting Division wrote.
Buying and selling up for Savaiinaea was sensible and will present a much bigger affect this season than the drafting of Grant. Nonetheless, it’s onerous to examine Miami getting early contributions from Day 3 choices like Jordan Phillips and Jason Marshall Jr.
Taking a flier on Quinn Ewers was sensible, given Tua Tagovailoa’s prolonged damage historical past. Ewers could by no means develop right into a high-level starter, however he can turn out to be a long-term backup for the Dolphins—they usually may positively use one.
General, although, it’s onerous to assume Miami will make an enormous 2025 bounce due to its draft class.
CBS Sports activities – Chris Trapasso
Grade: B
If nothing else, give a spherical of applause to basic supervisor Chris Grier for flipping the draft philosophy and eventually constructing by the trenches. Grant was picked too early for the nostril deal with place, but I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s among the best gamers at that area of interest spot in three or 4 years.
Savaiinaea is a dancing bear with positional versatility — which was wanted — and Phillips is a dynamic one-gap penetrator at defensive deal with. I didn’t love the 2 defensive again choices, though Marshall brings plus man-coverage abilities to the sphere. Gordon generally is a hammer at working again, he’ll praise Achane properly.
Fox Sports activities – Rob Rang
Grade: D+
I can respect the rationale behind GM Chris Grier’s resolution to pick out huge nostril guard Kenneth Grant at No. 13 general. When the Dolphins’ offense is wholesome and buzzing, opponents have little alternative however to attempt to run the ball to gradual them down — and Grant is completely suited to clog up these lanes. That mentioned, I imagine the Dolphins paid an terrible lot in draft capital for a participant who merely hasn’t dominated persistently — and the Dolphins spent two extra picks on Day 3 on the place (on Jordan Phillips and Zeek Biggers), as properly.
My favourite picks for Miami on this draft have been the burly blocker Jonah Savaiinaea within the second spherical and the late choices of working again Ollie Gordon (179th) and quarterback Quinn Ewers (231st), every of whom are intriguing suits in Mike McDaniel’s offense.
NBC Sports activities – Eric Froton
Grade: C+
Kenneth Grant and Savaiinaea shore up deficiencies on either side of the road with high quality, instant-contributors. The Phins needed to wait one other 105 choices earlier than taking a inventory and commerce run stuffer who didn’t file a sack over his three yr profession. Marshall Jr. and Dealer Jr. are rotational depth items, whereas RB Gordon may have short-yardage worth behind speedsters Achane and Jalen Wright. Quinn Ewers ought to have collected one other $3 million in NIL cash to switch to Notre Dame as a substitute of being a seventh spherical fringe clipboard holder who would possibly find yourself on the apply squad. Miami had a two-player draft with a sequence of substitute degree late picks.
New York Put up – Ryan Dunleavy
Grade: C-
Out of school teammate Mason Graham’s shadow, Grant is the run-stopper sorely lacking from this protection — therefore his over-drafting (No. 13). Going about 100 picks — no third- or fourth-rounder — with out choosing was too dangerous in a make-or-break yr. Savaiinaea provides a much-needed bodily presence to a finesse offense.
NFL.com – Chad Reuter
Grade: B+ (Day 1: B-, Day 2: A-, Day 3: A+)
Grant’s a possible drive on the line of defense, however Derrick Harmon (picked by the Steelers at No. 21 general) and Walter Nolen (taken by the Cardinals at No. 16) may show to be higher values. Miami went with one other huge physique in Savaiinaea to exchange Robert Jones at guard, although they gave up two mid-round picks and acquired one in return to maneuver up and choose Savaiinaea.
Miami correctly stockpiled a 2026 third-round decide as a substitute of selecting somebody within the fourth this yr. Phillips and Biggers confirmed the workforce’s dedication to stopping the run. Marshall lasted longer within the draft than I figured, given his protection abilities. Dealer goes to punish ball-carriers on the subsequent degree. I projected the cumbersome Gordon to Miami on Day 3 to convey a bodily presence. Ewers enters a QB room in Miami the place Tua Tagovailoa’s backups traditionally have tended to see their fair proportion of motion.
Professional Soccer Focus – PFF.com
Grade: B
Grant — The Dolphins may have gone in lots of instructions, however they opted to fill a void on the inside with a nostril deal with who possesses a uncommon mixture of dimension and quickness. Grant posted an 87.5 PFF run-defense grade (ninetieth percentile) in 2024 and is an improve over Benito Jones. This decide additional boosts a protection that ranked sixth in PFF run-defense grade final season.
Savaiinaea — After including some dimension to the inside line of defense in Spherical 1, Miami turns round and strikes as much as enhance the offensive line. Savaiinea has beginning expertise at each deal with and guard throughout three seasons at Arizona, and is smart as a match within the Dolphins’ zone speeding scheme. He graded out within the 88th percentile amongst qualifiers in PFF pass-blocking grade on true go units over the previous three seasons.
Phillips — The Dolphins get wonderful worth right here, as Phillips ranks No. 94 on the PFF Huge Board. He recorded an 11.0% pass-rush win charge and a 7.6% run-stop charge in 2024.
Dealer — Miami addresses the secondary once more with consecutive picks within the fifth spherical. Dealer has some versatility to play within the field, slot and deep. He improved his tackling woes, lowering his missed deal with charge from 18.3% in 2023 to 4.8% in 2024.
Gordon — Gordon’s greatest season at Oklahoma State was in 2023, when he ran for 1,732 yards and averaged 6.1 yards per try. In 2024, he earned a 75.8 PFF speeding grade on hole runs.
Ewers — Ewers was the One hundred and sixty fifth-ranked prospect on the PFF Huge Board, so the Dolphins obtained good worth with this decide. He can finally function a backup to Tua Tagovailoa. Though Ewers’ grades dipped in 2024 (72.5), he earned an excellent 86.8 PFF general grade in 2023.
Biggers — Biggers has prototypical dimension and size for the nostril deal with place, however his grading profile is underwhelming, given these traits. Biggers earned PFF grades of 65.0 or decrease in every of the previous two seasons for the Yellow Jackets.
Professional Soccer and Sports activities Community – PFSN Stats and Insights
Grade: C+
To the Dolphins’ credit score, they did what many individuals needed them to do: Concentrate on the trenches. They spent their first two picks, and half of their general choices, on trench gamers, and their second-round decide – Jonah Savaiinaea – was among the best confluences of want and “greatest participant out there” in your entire draft.
Savaiinaea must be an affect starter at guard, and though the Kenneth Grant choice was too wealthy, Grant does have excessive upside in a distinct segment the place that sort of two-phase, three-down potential is comparatively tough to seek out. The issue is, the Dolphins didn’t construct off of the Grant choice in addition to they may have.
They basically drafted three variations of nostril tackles. Jordan Phillips is a younger block absorber who provides little disruptive capacity at this cut-off date. Zeek Biggers is an explosive space-eater who’s additionally restricted past his major operate in the mean time.
Subsequent to Grant and Zach Sieler, the Dolphins nonetheless have a deficiency on the line of defense, and that might affect Grant’s improvement. However past that, Miami’s different picks have been stable sufficient.
Jason Marshall Jr. has some potential as a nickel defender, and Dante Dealer Jr. is a pure mover at security. Quinn Ewers was acceptable worth in Spherical 7, and if Ollie Gordon II can recapture his 2023 magic, he’ll be a steal. Miami did sufficient to remain afloat, however can they ship on their bolder picks? That continues to be to be seen.
The Rating – Dan Wilkins
Grade: B-
Run protection will now not be a difficulty in Miami. Grant is an enormous defensive deal with who dominates in that space, and he’s obtained extra pass-rush upside than you’d count on for a participant his dimension. Phillips can also be a dominant run defender who gives nice worth within the fifth spherical. Whereas Savaiinaea fills a necessity on the offensive line, and whereas his athleticism will definitely make him a slot in Mike McDaniel’s zone run recreation, it’s powerful to get on board with giving up a third-round decide to maneuver up 11 spots within the second spherical to get him. This roster may have used the additional Day 2 draft capital.
Sports activities Illustrated – Gilberto Manzano, Matt Verderame
Grade: C+
The Dolphins did properly with their choices, but it surely’s powerful to get a prime grade once you make solely two picks by the primary 4 rounds. Miami added a much-needed guard to its offensive line in Savaiinaea, who may begin as a rookie. Grant, their first-round decide, is a 331-pound run-stuffer who additionally gives some juice as a go rusher. He’ll match properly on a entrance 4 which incorporates Zach Sieler, Bradley Chubb and Jaelan Phillips. —MV
USA As we speak – Nate Davis
Grade: C- (lowest grade given)
They completely wanted to get more durable within the trenches – on each side of the ball. So from that standpoint, spending their solely picks forward of the fifth spherical on DT Kenneth Grant (Spherical 1) and G Jonah Savaiinaea (Spherical 2) made sense. Conversely, have been they each slight reaches relative to their draft place and even the most effective out there choices at their respective positions? The workforce’s spotty observe file, particularly on the O-line, makes one surprise.
Walter Soccer – Walt
Grade: B+
Targets Getting into the 2025 NFL Draft: Miami’s roster is in shambles. The offensive line is kind of probably the worst blocking unit within the NFL. The secondary appears to be atrocious. And the workforce can’t probably have any religion in Tua Tagovailoa staying wholesome, so some insurance coverage is required at quarterback.
2025 NFL Draft Accomplishments: The Dolphins made it some extent to handle the trenches. 4 of their picks have been spent on linemen, together with the primary three. Kenneth Grant started the run, as the massive Michigan nostril deal with will assist clamp down on the run and rush the passer. Miami’s subsequent choice was used to assist enhance the blocking.
The Dolphins had a robust draft general, although they made a few errors. First, whereas Ollie Gordon offered great worth within the sixth spherical, Miami ought to have continued to handle the various holes on the roster. Operating again was thought-about the bottom precedence. Second, Dante Dealer was a attain within the fifth spherical.
Regardless of these two gaffes, the Dolphins did properly on this draft. Excluding the Dealer choice, all however one among Miami’s picks scored a B+ or greater, and the lone exception earned a “B.”
Yahoo! Sports activities – Nate Tice, Charles McDonald
Grade: B-
Right here’s why: The Dolphins add to the trenches with their first two choices. Kenneth Grant isn’t somebody I had linked to Miami, but it surely’s a variety that I’ve appreciated the extra I’ve marinated on it. Grant is huge, athletic, sturdy in opposition to the run, and has upside as a disruptor in opposition to the run and go. His greatest ball is in entrance of him and he joins a Dolphins entrance that has some critical tooth to it. Jonah Savaiinaea is an enormous guard, however strikes properly (which matched his testing on the NFL scouting mix), making him an excellent match for the Dolphins. They moved as much as get Savaiinaea, and I might have appreciated them so as to add much more numbers to their line, however he suits a necessity and went within the correct vary of the place he was predicted to go. Dante Dealer Jr. is a fifth-round choice who provides the Dolphins extra our bodies at security.
Most attention-grabbing decide: Ollie Gordon II, RB, Oklahoma State
Gordon is a unique sort of taste at working again that the speed-addicted Dolphins have taken previously. He’s an enormous, bruiser who can construct up velocity in area. He was wildly productive in 2023, however some put on and tear slowed him down in 2024. De’Von Achane and Jaylen Wright already present loads of velocity, so now the Dolphins have a participant with some bulk to take powerful carries like on quick yardage.