Earlier this week, I requested:
Ought to our Miami Dolphins commerce Tyreek Hill this offseason, and if that’s the case or not, why?
I additionally had a ballot wherein I requested:
Ought to the Miami Dolphins commerce Tyreek Hill this offseason?
Beneath are the results-
62% or 133 of you said- Sure, however provided that you get a very good return in compensation.
22% or 58 of you said- Sure, get him out of right here already!
16% or 34 of you said- No, are you loopy?
Beneath are a few of your ideas and solutions to the PQOTD-
sdphinsfan says it depends upon your finish purpose.
In a world the place you’re attempting to construct a roster to win soccer video games, a number of video games towards good and dangerous groups, sure, you commerce him. In a world the place you’re constructing an leisure product, no. He can do issues with the ball in his palms that not many others can. That attracts eyeballs and entertains followers.
Word: If he’s traded to the Payments for something lower than Josh Allen, any individual must be arrested, investigated, tried, and convicted.
FinsRegard is towards buying and selling him as he does carry the offense.
Hill had 2 nice seasons right here.Final yr it was mentioned his wrist was damage, saved enjoying .Hill leaves and now Waddle or Smith is double teamed? When the Dolphins bought Hill I couldn’t imagine it , not like Suh Hill produced on the very highest degree.Is it logical that with Miami not having gained a playoff sport for 25 years it will commerce its finest participant, a participant who carried the offense for two seasons?Hill was a star in KC and right here in Miami to the purpose the digicam adopted him throughout the sport.
Dolfanjoe is appropriate in regards to the monetary ramifications. Even when they commerce him subsequent season, they might be clever to make him a post-June 1st lower.
To commerce Hill this season means we’re going to eat a complete bunch of cash. Subsequent yr not a lot ! What’s his worth to a group needing a pace extensive out who could make a distinction ? And naturally getting good commerce worth for him nonetheless means we now have to interchange him with one thing. Hold Hill except the commerce is simply unimaginable ! Put a greater operating sport on the sector and it’ll open again up our passing sport. Wow fundamental soccer, who ‘da thunk it !
EJPLAYA says no as a result of he carries an enormous lifeless cash hit this season. Per OTC, if he had been traded earlier than June 1st, the lifeless cash could be $28,297,500 (virtually 600K greater than his cap hit in any other case). A post-June 1st commerce would lead to $12,728,750 in lifeless cash and a financial savings towards the cap of $14,970,000. The numbers get a lot better subsequent low season for each eventualities. Fifty-six million {dollars} in lifeless cash would solely apply if he had been to be lower earlier than June 1st.
Hill carries a 57 million lifeless cap hit this season. By no means going to occur. If that weren’t the case I’d commerce him for a low 2nd and third to the cowboys for certain. forty fourth and 77th choose? We might get a excessive potential wr and a prime guard with that cash. Can’t take that lifeless cap hit although.
Lefty55555 doesn’t really feel like his effort final season lived as much as his contract.
When your agent calls for a elevate from 25M per yr to 30+M per yr, then you definately had higher carry out. He didn’t. I’m nonetheless pissed he didn’t go after his personal fumble early within the yr.
Yarganaught desires to maintain him except somebody brings the home in commerce worth.
Pulling himself out of the ultimate sport, which was out of attain and many of the group had additionally given up, is what a petulant little one does. OK, so he’s a toddler in a person’s physique. However, when he’s profitable, he seems to be a really supportive and enthusiastic group mate.
Is it a distraction… certain. Is it a relentless distraction… probably not. Not sufficient for my part to warrant a seat on the Diggs Prepare from Barfalo. However, if the Texans got here a-callin with some commerce bait, I might reply the cellphone.
Jptapt says if the return is true, then do it.
We want all the assistance we will get, and if the worth for that’s buying and selling Hill, I believe it’s a worth value paying – if we will get good worth for the deal.
SlayerNation1 believes that, for varied causes, nobody will now be keen to pay sufficient to make the commerce value it.
No.
I can’t see any group proffering a suitable quantity in a commerce. Hill is dear, noisy and after final season, it’s affordable to query if He has misplaced a step.
Hill mounted Tua (statistically and monetarily), make no mistake about it.
That being mentioned, the core of Hill, Tua, McD, Grier, Waddle must journey out 2025. They’re all in it collectively for a remaining season. Let’s see how they reply to that unseen degree of stress.
2025 needs to be very fascinating for all issues off the sector and Hill is the Ring Chief. It’s simply the truth We face for one more season.
glen55 wouldn’t thoughts!
I don’t care that a lot about Hill the polarizing determine, however I wouldn’t thoughts buying and selling him if the worth was proper. He had an off yr, and perhaps that was due to damage, nevertheless it’s not precisely unparalleled for a 30-year-old wideout to have an off yr after which come again and have extra off years after which retire. I don’t put his inventory as ihigh proper now because it was earlier than ‘24.
I’d quite be fallacious and have him come again and play like ‘22 and ‘23 once more than be proper. He’s enjoyable to observe.
Alley Gator goes for the quick and candy method!
Bye Felicia.
That is our random ten feedback. The consensus is that if the return is nice/wonderful, pull the set off and ship him packing. His lifeless cash could be huge both earlier than or after June 1st, however generally, like Denver did with Russel Wilson, it’s finest to eat the large hit in a single season and get it off the books for the long run. Both approach, I assume he will probably be right here via no less than this season, with it being rather more cost-effective to commerce or lower him subsequent low season. Thanks to every of you who took the time to reply our questions for the day. Please be a part of us once more tomorrow night for our weekly Victory Of The Week publish.
